So sorry about the delay in replying to your post above, Daniel. Can't think how I missed you.
I wish I could say I had the crucial article on me, but as is often the case when posting on ET, I was working from memory regarding the Seward account. However, I do recall that the suggestive clues regarding his cabin oriniate from an article relating specifically to W.T. Stead, in which Seward mentions some fascinating conversations he had with the editor over dinner one night at the purser's table. He refers specifically to the evening of April 14th, following an enjoyable meal at his usual table, and returning afterwards to his cabin "several decks below" . When the collision with the berg occured, he remembered a long scraping noise which caused immediate alarm. I suggested
E-deck becasue his personal experience of the ominous impact with the berg paralells several other passengers birthed on E-deck, i.e. loud and scraping, arousing them instantly from their sleep (
Molly Brown, Harder, Chambers to name a few). Passengers berthed on higher decks tended to have remembered a somewhat milder rumble and rarely mention any noise.
If I find the article in question, I will certainly post it here.
I always find it frustrating that so many passengers did not appear on the Cave list, or indeed on any other written or spoken piece of evidence that might pinpoint a passenger to a specific cabin. It remains tantalising at the same time, though, as it opens the doorway for some enjoyable and in-depth sleuthing, as I'm sure you experienced with the E-23 mystery!
Best Regards,
Ben