Seumas
Member
It's one thing to read the accounts of the survivors in their own words. It's something special though when you are able to actually listen to them recalling what they saw and heard that night.
How many survivors lived long enough to actually have their memories recorded on audio and/or audio-visual format ?
This could be TV or radio interviews, newsreels, tape recordings made by journalists, researchers or even just for their family.
I took a look around the web on YouTube, the BBC and British Pathe archives amongst others and found the following Titanic survivors whose voices were recorded for posterity -
First Class
Edith Russell
Second Class
Ruth Becker
Edith Brown
Eva Hart
Michel Navratil
Third Class
Frank Aks
Gus Cohen
Millvina Dean
Kate Gilnagh
Frankie Goldsmith*
Jirjis Yūsuf Tu'mah (subsequently known as George Thomas)
And for the crew.
Deck Crew
Joseph Boxhall
Charles Lightoller
George Rowe
Victualling Crew
Sid Daniels*
Arthur Lewis
Frank Prentice
Frederick Dent Ray
Maud Slocombe
James Witter
Engineering Crew
Wally Hurst
*I didn't actually hear the recordings of Daniels and Goldsmith. However, the latter's voice is apparently featured in the film "Titanica" (which I've never seen) and according to Dr Paul Lee, a museum in Southampton has a tape recording of Daniels being interviewed.
There must be a few more surely ? There are a number of likely candidates listed here - Last survivors to die after the disaster | Encyclopedia Titanica
Did any of Lawrence Beesley, Fred Fleet, Violet Jessop, Charles Joughin, Harold Lowe or Herbert Pitman ever have their voice recorded ?
In 1934, former crewman Albert Horswill, now living in the USA, gave a radio talk on his memories of the Titanic but although his complete script survives, no recording of Horswill actually giving his talk is known to exist. Do we know of anymore "lost" recordings whereby a survivor is known to have, for example, spoken over the radio or on television but alas no recording is known to exist ?
Asides from the survivors it's probably worth mentioning these four supplementary ones.
Sir Arthur Rostron gave a radio talk in the 1930s.
There is newsreel footage of Sir James Bisset speaking about taking charge of the Queen Elizabeth but I don't think he ever spoke on the radio or on camera about his memories of the Carpathia.
For a 1950s BBC TV interview, five of the survivors listed above - Cohen, Hurst, Rowe, Russell & Witter, were joined by Harold Cottam who even tapped out a few letters for the camera on a replica wireless set.
In 1961, Stanley Lord was recorded on tape for Leslie Harrison's research.
How many survivors lived long enough to actually have their memories recorded on audio and/or audio-visual format ?
This could be TV or radio interviews, newsreels, tape recordings made by journalists, researchers or even just for their family.
I took a look around the web on YouTube, the BBC and British Pathe archives amongst others and found the following Titanic survivors whose voices were recorded for posterity -
First Class
Edith Russell
Second Class
Ruth Becker
Edith Brown
Eva Hart
Michel Navratil
Third Class
Frank Aks
Gus Cohen
Millvina Dean
Kate Gilnagh
Frankie Goldsmith*
Jirjis Yūsuf Tu'mah (subsequently known as George Thomas)
And for the crew.
Deck Crew
Joseph Boxhall
Charles Lightoller
George Rowe
Victualling Crew
Sid Daniels*
Arthur Lewis
Frank Prentice
Frederick Dent Ray
Maud Slocombe
James Witter
Engineering Crew
Wally Hurst
*I didn't actually hear the recordings of Daniels and Goldsmith. However, the latter's voice is apparently featured in the film "Titanica" (which I've never seen) and according to Dr Paul Lee, a museum in Southampton has a tape recording of Daniels being interviewed.
There must be a few more surely ? There are a number of likely candidates listed here - Last survivors to die after the disaster | Encyclopedia Titanica
Did any of Lawrence Beesley, Fred Fleet, Violet Jessop, Charles Joughin, Harold Lowe or Herbert Pitman ever have their voice recorded ?
In 1934, former crewman Albert Horswill, now living in the USA, gave a radio talk on his memories of the Titanic but although his complete script survives, no recording of Horswill actually giving his talk is known to exist. Do we know of anymore "lost" recordings whereby a survivor is known to have, for example, spoken over the radio or on television but alas no recording is known to exist ?
Asides from the survivors it's probably worth mentioning these four supplementary ones.
Sir Arthur Rostron gave a radio talk in the 1930s.
There is newsreel footage of Sir James Bisset speaking about taking charge of the Queen Elizabeth but I don't think he ever spoke on the radio or on camera about his memories of the Carpathia.
For a 1950s BBC TV interview, five of the survivors listed above - Cohen, Hurst, Rowe, Russell & Witter, were joined by Harold Cottam who even tapped out a few letters for the camera on a replica wireless set.
In 1961, Stanley Lord was recorded on tape for Leslie Harrison's research.