Allan:
It seems as if you have your mind made up so I don't know if any more discussion will be persuasive.
Here are a few points for you to consider and questions that maybe you can answer:
1. If you look at the amalgamated "builders model" of Titanic as it now exists in the Merseyside Museum it still retains the A and B deck Britannic style windows which were there in 1957 at the time of the filming of "A Night to Remember".
2. Twenty years later, what I believe was a different model which had Olympic crudely lettered on the bow was discovered in storage and in poor condition at the Liverpool Airport.
3. This model was restored as I indicated by a Mr. Nelson-Ewen. The image I provided clearly shows that there are no Britannic type windows on A and B decks in this model.
To believe that this model in the image and the one currently on display at the Merseyside Museum
are the same model, you would have to believe that the correct Titanic A and B deck windows were altered to a Britannic style after the late seventies. To believe this seems preposterous.
Since it is clear that these are two different models, what happened to this more accurate Titanic model?
I am not presenting any of this evidence as some novel new theory. The entire story of this particular model was covered in an article in the Spring 1980 issue of the Titanic Commutator.
While I respect Mr. Davies-Garner's views on a number of subjects, I believe he was unaware of this second builders model. What ship it started out to represent, I do not know. Where it ended up, I also do not know. It was supposedly commissioned for restoration by the Merseyside County Museum but clearly the model in the image link and the one currently at the Merseyside Museum are not the same models.
Also, what evidence do you have that the Britannic builders model was merely a modification of the Olympic builders model?
Regards,
Bob Read