Hello Trent;
I don't know if you still post here or not but, you have the name of the thread already listed, so I won't re-start it.
I got very lucky this morning and caught the program you describe above on the History Channel. I'd seen it about 9 years ago but didn't tape it then. Today, I DID tape it!
I thought it was very interesting as well, but my curiosity is tweeked by the fact that several scenes of the ship sailing along and then later sinking seemed to me to be out-takes from "A Night To Remember". As I recall, the actual movie did not show the ship sticking out of the water for an extended period of time like this special did. Wonder where they got these out-takes? Also, in light of what we now know, it's interesting to view this kind of then-speculative stuff from Peter Padfield, Louis Gorman, et.al.
Maybe the "Great Shelly D." can tell us more about this special. {She seems to know everything else, why not this as well?}
Take Care,
Richard