Well done, Andrew, it was indeed a typo! I meant to type 1894, but as usual I type too fast.
Pilots are pilots, not listed crew or passengers. Irrelevant.
In relation to the claims made about William Wilson in 2005 - and you cite the lapse of time since 1912 in relation to sceptics of the story - can I say that I have been through all the Belfast, Southampton and Liverpool papers from April to December 1912 and have transcribed almost all of what is therein about the Titanic. Never once is the name of William Wilson mentioned, although of course there are many claims about people who were not on board.
It is, to me, perfectly explainable that there were no early reports of a Wilson family expressing worry about their member, or relating his lucky escape, or Harland and Wolff staff doing the same (they were quoted extensively). And it is explainable in that he was not aboard the vessel.
You are holding to a most contrary position - defending the veracity of something that was told to you, whether in writing or orally, by a person alive in 2005 about events, as you say, nearly a century ago.
I have no idea how old the descendant is now, but she either was alive in 1912 (in which case she would be prone to not only the tender innocence of childhood at the time but also to super-superannuated infirmity today), or else she was not. Your line of argument reflected back to you.
Second-hand information is hearsay in a court of law, and in journalism, and in most other walks of life I am sure, and to point it out does not grossly impugn anyone's character in the quasi-legalistic phrase earlier employed. The doubt, you see, is on the original teller, not the "tellee."
Now, someone made the claims to the Daily Mirror in connection with this auction that Wilson was on the Titanic. I note you say you haven't established that "yet."
It is, for the moment, an asserion that is without documentary provenance.
I will be glad to buy you copious pints if Alan announces this lot at Southampton in conjunction with the claim that Wilson was on the Titanic. I wager that he will not do so, mindful of his trade descriptions.
Here's another handy phrase:
"Dura veritas, sed veritas."
The truth is hard, but it is the truth.
Yes, I hope to get up to Belfast in March. Are you going to be in the Europa?
S