Harland Duzen
Member
Since joining this website and researching a Titanic book, I been writing since late 2016, I been surprised to find out how many myths or inaccurate stories have since morphed into fact and been reprinted in dozens of other Titanic Books and other forms of media.
This ranges from Newspaper stories by reporters of the time, authors meaningful attempts to fill in gaps in witness testimony (such as Walter Lord) or even theories by Authors taken as possibilities being aspected as fact.
Current Examples include:
1) Myth: The belief of Engineer Jonathan Shepherd drowning when Boiler Room 5 flooded due to a broken leg.
Reality: Upon breaking Leg is carried to Boiler Room 4 for safety. Possibly caused by Walter Lord either for dramatic effect or not knowing what actually happened.
2) Myth: Jack Phillips ''deafened'' by Californian's Cyril Evans message on ice who retaliates with a angry message who in turn shuts down wireless machine in anger.
Reality: No evidence to state Phillips was ''deafened'' as Evans is only surviving witness to event and doesn't mention it + Evans knew he accidentally ''jammed'' a message to Cape Race and so stopped to not further interrupt and didn't take offence.
3) Myth: Captain Lord was a angry and strict Captain who Crew feared and hated.
Reality: This claim was made by some Authors to explain the weird circumstances of the night of April 14th -15th. No evidence to prove this and the only hint of this is Charles Groves 3rd person letter stating ''wrath of his superior''.
4) Myth: When 2nd Officer Blair left Titanic at Southampton, he took the keys to the Crow's Nest which made the lookouts job more difficult.
Reality: Blair took the keys to the Crows Nest Telephone box which wasn't a problem. No box existed within the crow's nest to store binoculars and instead they have to get them from their storage in the officers quarters.
This forum can be used to by any want-to-be Titanic authors and hopefully rid any future novels from inaccuracies or mistakes.
This ranges from Newspaper stories by reporters of the time, authors meaningful attempts to fill in gaps in witness testimony (such as Walter Lord) or even theories by Authors taken as possibilities being aspected as fact.
Current Examples include:
1) Myth: The belief of Engineer Jonathan Shepherd drowning when Boiler Room 5 flooded due to a broken leg.
Reality: Upon breaking Leg is carried to Boiler Room 4 for safety. Possibly caused by Walter Lord either for dramatic effect or not knowing what actually happened.
2) Myth: Jack Phillips ''deafened'' by Californian's Cyril Evans message on ice who retaliates with a angry message who in turn shuts down wireless machine in anger.
Reality: No evidence to state Phillips was ''deafened'' as Evans is only surviving witness to event and doesn't mention it + Evans knew he accidentally ''jammed'' a message to Cape Race and so stopped to not further interrupt and didn't take offence.
3) Myth: Captain Lord was a angry and strict Captain who Crew feared and hated.
Reality: This claim was made by some Authors to explain the weird circumstances of the night of April 14th -15th. No evidence to prove this and the only hint of this is Charles Groves 3rd person letter stating ''wrath of his superior''.
4) Myth: When 2nd Officer Blair left Titanic at Southampton, he took the keys to the Crow's Nest which made the lookouts job more difficult.
Reality: Blair took the keys to the Crows Nest Telephone box which wasn't a problem. No box existed within the crow's nest to store binoculars and instead they have to get them from their storage in the officers quarters.
This forum can be used to by any want-to-be Titanic authors and hopefully rid any future novels from inaccuracies or mistakes.