So I'm marking the Titanic's 110th anniversary by reviving a three-year-old thread, haha.
In My Maiden Voyage, Roberta Maioni said that she was helped into one of the lifeboats by 'an elderly officer, tears streaming down his cheeks...He was Captain Smith—the master of that ill-fated vessel.' Now, unless I'm very much mistaken, Captain Smith remained on the bridge the entire time the lifeboats were being loaded except for occasional trips to the wireless shack. None of the other survivors mention seeing the Captain anywhere near the lifeboats that night. Since My Maiden Voyage was written in 1926, it's possible that Miss Maioni's memories simply got muddled the way they tend to do over time. But if Miss Maioni wasn't referring to the Captain when she penned My Maiden Voyage and she knows that it wasn't the Captain, then she was either embellishing or else outright lying in her account.
This inaccuracy suggests that parts of her accounts of her experience on the Titanic could have been similarly made up or exaggerated or simply confused. Miss Maioni's Titanic legacy is for the 'real-life Jack-and-Rose-esque' love story that supposedly happened when she fell in love with a steward whom gave her a White Star badge for safekeeping before he perished in the Atlantic. The story itself seems...........not very plausible to me for a lot of reasons. Yet Miss Maioni did have the White Star pin, proving that something happened between her and a crew member onboard.
So, what does everyone think? Could there have been some other way she acquired the badge? Or did a shipboard romance really happen and I'm just too cynical to believe it?