Peyton Jenkins
Guest
Hi everyone...
Lately I have been doing a lot of reading and study on the Titanic, and I keep coming across a lot of different numbers for the total survivors, everywhere from 705 to 712. I was curious to know how there could be such a broad fluctuation, but I think I have come to a pretty reasonable answer and just wanted others' opinions.
It seems to me that it must be that some people count the babies still in their mothers' wombs and others don't. Think about all the pregnant women who were saved (Madeleine Astor, of course, being the most prominent): Surely they can each count for two survivors, for if they had been lost, then their babies would never have been born. Similarily, there must be a higher number of lost lives counting pregnancies. So many, that nobody could ever possibly know the exact number, considering how there were probably women who did not yet know they were pregnant, and possibly some who were even impregnated on the Titanic itself.
Anyway, just wondering what the rest of you thought: Should pregnant women on the Titanic be counted as two?
(DISCLAIMER: By no means am I trying to spark an angry political debate... just looking for opinions)
Lately I have been doing a lot of reading and study on the Titanic, and I keep coming across a lot of different numbers for the total survivors, everywhere from 705 to 712. I was curious to know how there could be such a broad fluctuation, but I think I have come to a pretty reasonable answer and just wanted others' opinions.
It seems to me that it must be that some people count the babies still in their mothers' wombs and others don't. Think about all the pregnant women who were saved (Madeleine Astor, of course, being the most prominent): Surely they can each count for two survivors, for if they had been lost, then their babies would never have been born. Similarily, there must be a higher number of lost lives counting pregnancies. So many, that nobody could ever possibly know the exact number, considering how there were probably women who did not yet know they were pregnant, and possibly some who were even impregnated on the Titanic itself.
Anyway, just wondering what the rest of you thought: Should pregnant women on the Titanic be counted as two?
(DISCLAIMER: By no means am I trying to spark an angry political debate... just looking for opinions)