View attachment 112249
Tad Fitch
5.0 out of 5 stars An incredibly detailed study of the Titanic/Californian affair.
Reviewed in the United States on January 30, 2020
Verified Purchase
Anyone who is familiar with Sam Halpern's previous work, knows how detailed his research is, and how he takes great care to remain objective. Such is the case with this book. What is unique is that unlike previous works on this very controversial subject, which have all been agenda driven and selective in their use of facts (with one or two exceptions), Halpern doesn't rely on a subjective interpretation of eyewitness statements, many of which are contradictory. Yes, the witness accounts are examined, but then, areas where facts can be confirmed (using multiple lines of evidence) are subjected to scientific and navigational analysis, and only then are any conclusions drawn. Defenders of Captain Lord who feel he did nothing wrong, as well as those who feel he could have rescued everyone from Titanic, will both find something to be unhappy about in this book. This proves the author had the correct approach, and that the book wasn't written to prove a point, the facts be damned. This is essential reading for anyone interested in the topic. A word of warning, it is a hefty read and will take a lot of patience and focus to get through, if read cover-to-cover. At 17 chapters in length, plus appendices, it is one that researchers will come back to again and again, but is not a leisurely read or coffee table book. The chapter summaries recap important facts and conclusions for the lay reader. Highly recommended.
8 people found this helpful