Your irony will be missed by those at whom it is directed, Jim.
I like Beesley. This science master shut himself up in a room on landfall and wrote an instant book. He was not influenced in any way. Judging from his letter to
The Times, he started writing detailed notes on the
Carpathia.
Beesley wrote chronologically. Leaving aside questions as to the reliability of individual timekeeping, Beesley said his boat was in the water at 12.45am. He says this in two places.
His boat was No. 13. Several lifeboats had gone before.
Look at what is said about lifeboat 13 -
"Mr Beesley had left the steamer in the same boat that I had… The statement of facts by Mr Beesley coincides exactly with my observations." - Washington Dodge.
Lookout Reg Lee (Saved in No. 13) -
2582. Did you see any rockets sent up from the
Titanic? – Yes, Sir.
2583. Before you left the vessel? –
Before and after.
2584. Were they coloured rockets, or only white ones? – No,
coloured rockets.
…
2680. Was it before or after the lowering of your boat that you saw the rockets first go up? –They were sending them up before the boat was lowered into the water.
Beesley subsequently made a statutory declaration, that included the following -
The widespread implication is that many rockets were fired before the first, orderly, lifeboats were launched, and then many more afterwards. To Beesley's eight fired while aboard must be added those seen by Lee when it was launched...
Boxhall's "between half a dozen and a dozen" gives a mean of NINE, and this before he is rung up from the poop to be told that a lifeboat is in the water.
Rowe and Bright (having been worried about being isolated at the stern with the steerage "where the wild things are" - away from the boat deck island) then bring forward more boxes of rockets. And start to fire them.
Separate to Boxhall. There is evidence of two separate firing positions thereafter. Rockets were then going up "simultaneously" and "incessantly."
Stone noticed plenty of shooting stars from his vantage point some 20 miles away. When he decided he had seen five did not mean only five had been fired. It was likely substantially more than that, and he had missed a number. Beware of revers deduction from what was seen on the
Californian. It means nothing as to what was done on
Titanic. For one thing,
Californian did not see any of the coloured rockets mentioned by Lee and many others (possibly they did not ascend as high).
Many, many rockets fired. I would be very surprised if it was as few as 12.
The above shows that the plethora of rockets can be demonstrated in relation to just one lifeboat.
The evidence is widespread.