Arun Vajpey
Member
Someone could have persuaded him to claim so. Such things have happened before.Why would an 85-year-old man decide to pass himself off as a survivor of the Titanic?
You are still not getting it, are you? There was never a listed Titanic survivor by the name of W. Belford and so Walter Lord or anyone else could not have "thought" that there was a survivor by that name, any more than he would have 'thought' that there was a survivor named Napoleon Bonaparte.So Lord was writing people he thought were survivors. How he got their names and addresses, I can't guess. And where would anyone get W. Belford's name? And when?
There was a Titanic victim named W(illiam) Bedford. As you pointed it out yourself, it was mentioned in that 1912 publication as below.
A booklet titled ' "Titanic" Disaster, Report of the Committee On Commerce United States Senate' published by the Washington Government Printing Office, 1912 (reprinted by 7C's Press) contains, under Exhibits, Exhibit A.---Alphabetical List of Crew on Steamship "Titanic." On that list under Victualing Department is the name W. Belford, 163 Manor Road, Itchen, Hants, assistant cook.
Despite the slight spelling error of the surname, the address was that of William Bedford who had died in the disaster. If somehow Walter Lord had missed the fact that William Bedford had died in the sinking and written to that address in the 1950s, it would NOT have reached Walter Bedford because he was not living there - never did. It was only if Walter Bedford was already passing himself off as a "Chief Night Baker" on the Titanic who lived at that Itchen address back in 1912 could Lord have written to him for information.
The only other possibility, although I think it is unlikely is that Walter Lord saw that report and realized that there was an Assistant Cook named "W Belford" on board the Titanic but somehow missed the fact that he had died in the sinking. If Lord then had started publicly looking for a man named W Belford who lived at that address back in 1912, Walter Belford or someone acting on his behalf could have jumped in on the bandwaggon and contacted Lord.