Marty! I KNEW that the owner of NYC's most legendary collection of music would surface in this context!
>Laurie, by Dickie Lee, from 1965
Are you familiar with "Margo?" Not the Big Band singer, but the ca. 1963 song by The Browns, of The Three Bells fame? It's the convoluted tale in which a young couple, ca 1910, are out in the coach when a newfangled automobile frightens the horse, which bolts and hurls "Margo" to an awful death. Jump ahead to 1963, and the young man is now an embittered senior with a pathological hatred of cars, and Margo, in turn, haunts the roadside where she was killed.
"Partners" is another great death-and-supernatural song from that era. Man kills his mining partner and throws his body out into the storm, only to get snowed in, go insane, and be left pondering if the shadowy figure knocking at the door in the final stanza is the titular Partner looking for his gold, or Satan.
"Bringing Mary Home" has a haunting melody, but is just the standard "vanishing hitch hiker" plot and one sees the end coming from a mile off.
"Long Black Veil" with its interesting look at an odd double damnation is probably the best of the death and haunting cycle.
"Leader of the Pack" is, beyond a doubt, the outre champion of the field.
"Tell Laura" and "Teen Angel" are just painful.
"Big Joe and Phantom 309" ended the cycle, ca. 1976. Never much cared for that one, but was amused when "Big Joe" turned up as "Large Marge" in Pee Wee's Big Adventure.
...and, yes, Mr. Oppenheim, the Frog People of Danbury are for real. Many a friend of a friend has spotted them late nite doing their grocery shopping or laundry