Hey Everybody,
I've been looking at the photo that Don very kindly took the time to post and, while the last thing I want to do is cause upset or put the cat among the pigeons, I must say that I have my doubts.
On the face of it, the circumstantial evidence is good. A photo of a callow youth of around 17 years old, taken in a Post Office telegraph room, posted in Surrey and addressed to a 'Miss Phillips'.
There is a similarity in the facial shape of the boy in the picture, but having compared it to those of both Jack Phillips and his father, I am not convinced, especially by his eyes. It's true that in 1904, Jack was working for the Post Office, but in the Godalming Branch not Woking (which is around 30 minutes away by car).
Without an initial it is impossible to tell if 'Miss Phillips' was Ethel or Elsie, or indeed one of the Phillips Aunts, and the address is unfamiliar.
The thing that bothers me most, however,is the sign off. 'Kindest Regards Reg' just doesn't add up to me as, surely 'Reg' is short for 'Reginald'? I've seen a fair amount of Jack's correspondence over the years and have only ever seen him use three variations of his signature. When writing to his family he commonly wrote simply 'Love Jack'. Naturally it is impossible to say for sure without seeing the handwriting on the card but those are my thoughts, for what they are worth. As I said, I have no desire to cause upset but I thought I should raise my concerns.
All the best - Mandy.